New York Red Bulls Will Head to Los Angeles Down After 1-0 Defeat
The New York Red Bulls had their last home match of the 2011 season against the Los Angeles Galaxy, the first of a home-and-away playoff series with the winner advancing to the Western Conference Final.
New York controlled possession, took more shots, won more corner kicks, and had better passing accuracy than the Galaxy, but ultimately lost the match 1-0 in typical Red Bull fashion, falling victim to a Galaxy goal coming off of a set piece. Replays showed Robbie Keane clearly offside and debatably involved in the play as he moved toward goal. However it was former New York player Mike Magee who took advantage of five Red Bulls defenders raising their hands asking for an offsides call and volleyed a shot past New York goalkeeper Frank Rost.
Just before half-time, a carelessly attempted header from Dane Richards back to Rost was intercepted by Robbie Keane, but Rost came off his line quickly and pressured Keane into squandering the opportunity. The Galaxy almost made it 2-0 again when in the 55th minute Todd Dunivant sent an ambitious long ball to a wide open Landon Donovan, who was left unmarked as Tim Ream slipped and fell down. Rost came up big once again, deflecting the shot wide, and L.A. would not have another good attempt on goal for the rest of the match.
New York had countless opportunities that tended to end with a shot off target or one pass or touch too many. Thierry Henry had a fancy bicycle kick attempt, Carlos Mendes put a headed corner kick just over the post, and Joel Lindpere had a great one-timed shot off a Dane Richards cross that Josh Saunders made a fantastic reaction save on.
The Red Bulls continued to control possession and attack late into the match but manager Hans Backe did not sacrifice any defensive cover in an attempt to draw level. Backe's lone change in the match involved moving Dane Richards up top and bringing in Mehdi Ballouchy for Luke Rodgers. Rafa Marquez came inches from equalizing in stoppage time with a shot from just outside the eighteen yard box, and that about did it for New York until the final whistle. Rafa Marquez caught Saunders' goal kick after the match ended, and seemed to dislike Donovan's reaction flinging the ball at him from a medium-distance. The ball bounced off Donovan's leg, and after a short skirmish at midfield, red cards were issued to Rafa Marquez and Juninho who will both miss the second leg in Los Angeles. While the suspensions are not reviewable by MLS except under the condition of mistaken identity, nothing prevents the league from doling out additional punishments after further review, an unlikely step at this point however.
There was a great turnout and atmosphere at Red Bull Arena, and the field conditions wound up not playing too large a factor in the match outside of Ream falling down on Donovan's attempt-on-goal. Landon Donovan went out of his way in his post-game comments to call out the Red Bulls for cheap and dirty play throughout the season, only adding to the great anticipation for the Thursday night rematch that will decide who advances to the conference final.
7 comments
|
Add comment
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Field conditions were not great and it wasn't even a sellout
“There was a great turnout and atmosphere at Red Bull Arena, and the field conditions wound up not playing too large a factor”
Were we at the same arena yesterday? The place was barely 2/3 full and the crowd was taken out of the game in the first half following the Galaxy’s goal. The Red Bulls can’t even sellout their only playoff game of the year? Unbelievable. They can sellout a Chicago game in August but not a playoff game versus the top team in the league L.A.. What gives with that?
There were two HUGE ruts running across the field on either side of the center line. There was a smaller rut in front of one of the goal boxes. It looked like a snow plow had gotten out of control a scraped the turf off of the pitch. A shame for the Red Bulls with their national television audience.
by icepickphil on Oct 31, 2025 8:44 AM EDT reply actions
Can't sell out?
A huge chunk of the Northeast got a foot of snow. My town is going to be without power until Thursday, probably.
I still got to the game. But I’m not going to begrudge anyone for no-showing, it was hell outside. My block had at least 5 or 6 downed trees.
Staff Writer at Once a Metro. Yankees/Giants/Rangers fan, too.
by Matt Coyne on Oct 31, 2025 10:28 AM EDT up reply actions
Not sure where you were sitting
Considering how nasty it was outside just 12 hours before game time I thought the grounds crew did relatively well salvaging the field. I never said the field was pristine, just that the ruts and mud didn’t have a large impact on the quality of the game or the outcome.
As far as the atmosphere goes, sure the goal took a little energy out of the crowd, but early in the second half when New York started picking it back up there was as much excitement and enthusiasm as for any match I’ve been to this season.
by Dan Ferris on Oct 31, 2025 10:34 AM EDT up reply actions
I'll tell you what gives
People like you who come in here and whine about attendance for a game that we only knew would happen late on Wednesday night, a day after a record snowstorm that caused power outages and deaths across the northeast. And, to make things better, MLS had the foresight to schedule the match at the same time as the Giants game against Miami.
This is the first time we’ve ever had problems with the pitch at Red Bull Arena. Maybe, just maybe, the snow had something to do with that.
Managing Editor, OnceAMetro.com
by Ben Schneider on Oct 31, 2025 11:07 AM EDT up reply actions
People Like Me?
Point taken Mr. Editor but I will disagree. Game of the year vs. the leagues top team.
If you want to call that whining then go for it — it’s your website!
by icepickphil on Oct 31, 2025 4:12 PM EDT up reply actions
What game were you at?
3 days notice, a snow and ice storm that left literally millions in the area without power, and we still had at least 18,000 loud and rowdy people at the game. It was a great atmosphere.
As for the game itself, rough outcome. The team really didn’t play terribly, but I didn’t think we attacked as a unit enough. We had a number of chances but not enough good ones. I think Henry really needs to pick up his focus offensively. He’s working fairly hard without the ball, but I think he makes some lazy decisions with it. His passing was a bit off. He needs to do better.
At least there’s still a chance…
by Joamiq on Nov 2, 2025 5:07 PM EDT up reply actions
I thought the atmosphere was great...
Very respectable attendance considering the storm, short window to sell tickets and other factors involved. Every week there’s someone whining about RBNY attendance. Just give it a rest. I had to drive on icy roads dodging downed power lines and fallen trees to get there. I know others who didn’t even have any power at all at their homes. The field was not great, but we’ve never before had a home match the day after an unexpected snowstorm. Despite the rough patches the it played OK.
Editor, OnceaMetro.com
by M.L. Conroy on Oct 31, 2025 1:28 PM EDT reply actions
Something to say? Choose one of these options to log in.

- » Create a new SB Nation account
- » Already registered with SB Nation? Log in!

by Dan Ferris on 










