Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook

Some Clarity on Tim Cahill's Goal


In case you missed it, the Red Bulls 3-2 comeback victory over the Portland Timbers wasn't without controversy.

The goal that Tim Cahill opened his New York account with seemed like it was blown dead for a penalty on a handball in the box. But it wasn't and the goal counted.

Thankfully, a "referee pool reporter" -- a reporter designated by each team to ask questions of the referee post-game, it seems -- got an explaination from the man in question, Jason Anno...

Pool Reporter Question: On the Red Bulls' second goal, what did you see on the play?

Answer: On the second goal, No. 11 McCarty took a shot and it redirected off a Portland player to No. 17 Cahill who shot and scored.

Pool Reporter Question: Did you blow your whistle?

Answer: Yes, when the ball entered the goal.

Pool Reporter Question: In your view, was it an advantage play?

Answer: Yes.

Whether or not these "pool reporter" quotes are supposed to get out or not, I guess it's nice to have an explanation.

Tweet Comment 3 comments  |  Add comment  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Once A Metro

New York Red Bulls 2-2 DC United: Recap & Reaction

Aug 2012 by Ben Schneider - 0 comments

New York Red Bulls vs. DC United: Live Match Thread

Aug 2012 by Ben Schneider - 0 comments

New York Red Bulls vs. Sporting Kansas City: Live Match Thread

Aug 2012 by Ben Schneider - 58 comments

Comments

Display:

He’s lying, obviously. CLEARLY the whistle went before the ball hit the net.

by Alan Clark on Aug 20, 2025 9:02 PM EDT reply actions  

mls refereeing is such bullshit

Lying in the face of clear evidence. The fans of every team need to keep demanding better refereeing. What can mls do to get FIFA to listen though?

by luckystriker on Aug 20, 2025 9:40 PM EDT via iPhone app reply actions  

Pool Reporter Question: Did you blow your whistle?
Answer: Yes, when the ball entered the goal.

So, the official explanation he’s choosing to go with then is: humans don’t possess the capabilities of sight and hearing.

Interesting choice.

by Jack Acid on Aug 21, 2025 3:24 PM EDT reply actions  


User Tools

Welcome to Once A Metro, the SB Nation blog for the New York Red Bulls and Sky Blue FC.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Superbowlmuffaletta02052012_small
Three Thoughts on NYRB v. NE
Cally_small
Casual Fan Needs Help
274_small
Where Is US Soccer Headed?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

9 Ben Schneider

Editors

Ferris_profile_photo_small Dan Ferris

Img_3571_small M.L. Conroy

37172_1464854616496_1087410181_31248912_5650398_n_small Matt Coyne

Writers

Untitled_small Dig Deep

Howard_cross_small bigbluethruandthru

Small Lauren Barker