Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Updated MMA Fighting iPhone app is here!

New York Red Bulls vs. Montreal Impact: Recap & Reaction

This was a proverbial 'find a way to win' game. The New York Red Bulls pulled out a scrappy 2-1 win despite playing the last third of the game a man down and never really threatening Donovan Ricketts' goal for extended periods...but a win is most definitely a win, and the Red Bulls have now won FIVE games in a row for the first time since 2003. If you're not deliriously happy, what is wrong with you?

The Red Bulls set up with a 4-5-1 again, a regular approach of late for Hans Backe in away games. They failed to make their numerical advantage in midfield count for much, and Victor Pálsson's defensive role was limited by the booking he took for a nasty tackle early in the first half. Yet again, the New York midfield didn't protect the backline enough (I'm going to keep saying this until it changes).

It was, for the most part, a fairly dull regular season game -- complete with a healthy dose of atrocious refereeing. Neither of the penalties awarded in the first half were particularly convincing, and the penalty given to Montreal was particularly ridiculous. Mr. Elfath gave a spot-kick for a handball by Markus Holgersson, who was facing away from the ball when it hit his hand. It was one of the worst refereeing decisions in a league full of terrible officials. Victor Pálsson was sent off in the second half, but this was his fault for committing a series of stupid fouls.

Star-divide

The Red Bulls bounced back pretty well from going a goal down, and took the few chances they did create. Cooper smashed New York's penalty to level the scores late in the first half, and Dane Richards drilled home from inside the box to give the Red Bulls a lead midway through the second half.

Montreal didn't put New York under sustained pressure until the final few minutes, and Ryan Meara was, yet again, up to the task of saving just about everything shot towards him. There wasn't much brilliance in the win, although the Red Bulls got good performances from Richards, Cooper, Dax McCarty, and the defense. Next up is a home match against Chivas USA before a three-and-a-half-week break.

Selected Stats (NY - MTL)

Possession: 40% - 60%

Passing Accuracy: 68% - 81%

Total Passes: 302 - 471

Corners: 3 - 5

Open Play Crosses: 12 - 22

Fouls: 15 - 8

Shots (On Goal): 12(4) - 20(6)

Tweet Comment 2 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Once A Metro

New York Red Bulls vs. Chicago Fire: Live Match Thread

Jun 2012 by Ben Schneider - 14 comments

New York Red Bulls vs. Charleston Battery: Live Match Thread

May 2012 by Ben Schneider - 28 comments

The Red Bulls Have Never Won in Charleston

May 2012 by Matt Coyne - 1 comment

Around SB Nation

Dynamo at Red Bulls: The Sojourn is Almost Over

May 2012 from Dynamo Theory - 2 comments

Toronto FC vs Montreal Impact: A Lackluster Performance, A Game to Forget

May 2012 from Mount Royal Soccer - 3 comments

Bryan Meredith Has Come Impressively Far, Impressively Fast

May 2012 from Sounder At Heart - 58 comments

Montreal Impact vs LA Galaxy : Montreal stay unbeaten at home

May 2012 from Mount Royal Soccer - 0 comments

The Week That Was in Major League Soccer: Round 10

May 2012 from Hot Time In Old Town - 0 comments

Comments

Display:

this stretch without Henry

has been all that you could ask for.

The defense stepped up, you got goals from non-forwards, along with a steady performance from Cooper (he’s now just 1 goal behind whatsisname for the Golden Boot,) and great goalkeeping from Meara.

Even marquez had a hand in a win. (BTW what happened to him in this match?)

They now stand just one point behind idle RSL (with a game in hand) for the Supporter’s Shield. After week 3 would you have thought that possible?

audivi in sellariis

by ianua ditis on May 19, 2025 11:03 PM EDT reply actions  

Even worse than the penalties

because they evened out, were the card decisions. Palsson probably deserved his for stupid play, but to not show a red for the studs up slide that whiped out Lade was a crime. That was an ankle breaking tackle, and I mean that in a literal sense not as a euphemism. Not pulling a red for that is just not following the rule book. Almost as bad was not showing a yellow to that Brazilian bitch midfielder who spiked McCarty. Clear studs to the leg, and he walks away Scot free. The ref was completely overmatched for 2/4 of this game.

Two Super Bowls in five years. Apparently I root for the luckiest team in the history of professional sports. I'll take it.

by bigbluethruandthru on May 20, 2025 9:45 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Once A Metro, the SB Nation blog for the New York Red Bulls and Sky Blue FC.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Cally_small
Casual Fan Needs Help
274_small
Where Is US Soccer Headed?
Mo_rivera_small
Drogba?
249945_2122604108170_1337871511_32436577_3888976_n__1__small
Ismail Elfath and Refereeing in the Red Bulls-Montreal MLS Match
Small
Travelling to Union game this Sunday?
Superbowlmuffaletta02052012_small
enough already with the tackle

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories


Managing Editor

9 Ben Schneider

Editors

Img_1342_small Dan Ferris

Img_3571_small M.L. Conroy

37172_1464854616496_1087410181_31248912_5650398_n_small Matt Coyne

Writers

Untitled_small Dig Deep

Howard_cross_small bigbluethruandthru

Small Lauren Barker